The Trouble with Jesus

by Constance Hastings

Betrayed by the Best of Them
March 28, 2023

 Before Jesus even got into town, they lined the road, spreading a carpet of coats, waving branches and shouting, “Hosanna to the Son of David!” Expectations were high. If only he had come to fulfill them…With too much popularity and too many attacks on the powers-that-be, Jesus wasn’t making it easy on himself. Sooner or later, someone was going to put a stop to this. As it was, it wasn’t only one.

You know, this just about sums up why you never really made it. Honestly, riding into town on a jackass! Your antagonists must have gone nuts with snide comments seeing this. Don Quixote got his inspiration from you, right? Jesus, delusional doesn’t even hint at what you were thinking. Let your crowds get silly over you. They’ll learn soon enough where you’re headed. Don’t expect them to cheer for you then. They’ll turn faster than a dizzy skater in a spin.

 

Crowds were everywhere, and if you hadn’t heard about him before, this week you couldn’t miss it. Before Jesus even got into town, they lined the road, spreading a carpet of coats, waving branches and shouting, Hosanna, ironically meaning, “Save us now!” Expectations were high. If only he had come to fulfill them.

 

All accounts record it. It must have been quite the procession. Everyone came out to see the spectacle of Jesus riding into Jerusalem on a jittery donkey, not a battle-strong stallion. People spread their coats on the ground, and the road was strewn with leafy branches, all to make the ride smoother and keep down the dust. Clamorous voices called him a king, the one who would establish a new kingdom on the level of their greatest hero, King David. Best yet, he came “in the name of the Lord,” fulfilling what the ancient prophets had promised. Not lost on anyone was the celebration of Passover only days away, the commemoration of the Israelite deliverance from slavery and oppression by the Egyptians. Part parade, part protest, however you see it, God was on the move and doing it again!

 

You’re right though to ridicule it, this parody, a caricature of royal processions for which Romans were notorious. Their hero had never called up an army or plotted overthrow of the regime. While the people thought they’d only be saved by military rebellion and nationalism, Jesus had called to turn the other cheek and love one’s enemy. Instead, he was being promoted as everything he was not. 


By Thursday, the strain was stretching him and the disciples. He had made a scene at the Temple, literally throwing out merchants who were gouging the faithful for Passover sacrifices.  He healed people right there and sparred with the lead priests over the attention he was getting and where he thought he got the right to do what he was doing. He even insinuated sinners like prostitutes would have a better chance getting into heaven before they did. Calling them hypocrites, he charged, “For you cross land and sea to make one convert, and then you turn him into twice the son of hell as you yourselves are.”


With too much popularity and too many attacks on the powers-that-be, Jesus wasn’t making it easy on himself. Sooner or later, someone was going to put a stop to this. As it was, it wasn’t only one.

 

The First Betrayal

Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples, has lived in infamy as the betrayer of Jesus. Sizing up the situation, he could tell the religious leaders not only wanted him out of their hair, but even more so, permanently out of the way. With the deal of 30 silver coins, he only had to seize the moment. (Matthew 26:14-16)   Jesus made it easy for him. Over the Passover meal, Jesus said, “One of you will betray me.” While Judas played at acting as a faithful follower, Jesus let him know he knew what Judas would do. From there, it was only a matter of a kiss to identify Jesus as the one the mob should drag away. 

 

His Closest Betrayer

But Judas wasn’t the only one. Jesus also told the twelve, “Tonight, all of you will desert me.” Not being one to show himself by deed rather than declaration, Peter insists he never will. As he had been clear to Judas, Jesus was now just as forthright with Peter. “The truth is, this very night, before the rooster crows, you will deny me three times.”   


Before sunrise, while the kangaroo court assembled by the high priests were condemning him, Peter’s words were, “I swear by God, I don’t know the man.” 

 

Was he denying that he had followed Jesus, or that the Jesus he followed was not the leader he thought Jesus would be?

 

An Unholy Alliance

Pilate, a Roman governor, was tasked with keeping Jerusalem and the Jews under control. The system allowed for them to have their religion as long as the Romans had a say in leadership. Ultimately, though the religious authorities wanted Jesus dead, they were not permitted to execute offenders of the faith on their own. While that morning Judas hanged himself in remorse after realizing where this was headed, and Peter along with the rest of the disciples abandoned him, Jesus was dragged in front of Pilate by the leading priests with charges he claimed to be King of the Jews, an indication he would overthrow the Roman government.

 

Pilate is caught in the middle. He can’t ignore such a charge, but he seems to have a handle on what these Temple tetrarchs were scheming. Seemingly looking for a way out, he urges Jesus to make a defense, but he won’t talk. It’s not what his accusers say, but rather the way they say it. They had been looking for a Messiah, but they didn’t want this Messiah. So they did what they could to do away with him. Thus, those set apart for holy office among the chosen people turned on him.

 

Meanwhile, Pilate tries again. He offers them a carrot. For the holy day, the Romans would release a Jewish prisoner. Figuring he could make them choose the lesser of two evils, Pilate offers the crowd either Jesus or the notorious criminal Barabbas. The priests though work the crowd to call for Barabbas’ release. Pilate can’t see what Jesus could have done that would be so bad for them, but the crowd, some of whom had likely cried Hosana earlier in the week, roars for more. “Crucify him!”

 

Pilate literally washes his hands of the matter as the crowd takes responsibility for Jesus’ execution. In an act of bloody mercy, Pilate orders Jesus flogged with a lead-tipped whip. It will make his death come faster. To avoid a riot and to protect his job, Pilate orders Jesus’ crucifixion.

 

Betrayed by Abandonment

Torture and mockery follow. More beatings, a crown of thorns, nailed through flesh and bone, Jesus is crucified, a death designed to be slow, painful, smothering as lungs collapse and blood flows. The King of the Jews has taken the cup of bitter wine, the cup of his own blood, and life oozes out.


The only faithful witnesses to his demise are the women who followed and supported him, women to whom he’d given honor and status, now rendered as impotent as he. But even they stood watching from a distance, distraught and detached at the same time. The comfort they were called to give wasn’t available to him when he needed it most.

 

Even the sky felt it. A weird darkness fell around noon. Three hours later, Jesus calls to heaven, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” He dies, abandoned in the will of God to take death upon himself, death that separates, rejects, leaves him alone with all that the worst of the world could do. 

 

Was Judas the one who betrayed Jesus? Or rather, who along with Judas deserted and betrayed him? His best friends, the leaders of his faith, the fickle crowd, the prevailing political system, the women who had anointed his feet in adoration all had a part. Most heart wrenching of all though must have been his God, the very part of himself that had set this in motion since the first animal sacrifice in that garden.

 

To be covered in such shame that you can’t stand yourself is how he died. It was shame that was not of his own doing, but a shame Jesus accepted for himself that isolates one from love of God and love of neighbor. In this then, he knew a hell which he wanted no one to ever know.

 

But what of those who won’t accept what his death meant for them?

Would this be the ultimate in betrayal?

 

Matthew 21:1-11, Matthew 26, Matthew 27:1-55

 

Subscribe to The Trouble with Jesus Blog Here.

 

 

The Trouble with Jesus: His conversations sometimes take you deeper than you want to go
By Constance Hastings March 2, 2026
The Trouble with Jesus: His conversations don’t stay on the surface, sometimes pulling you deeper than you want to go. He drags you into the deep end before you even realize you’re swimming.
The Trouble with Jesus: He wouldn’t water his message into how people wanted to hear it.
By Constance Hastings February 23, 2026
Maybe it was just the way Jesus said it. Maybe if he had said that you gotta change your life and priorities without losing yourself, it’d make more sense. Maybe if he had said you find God by keeping the commandments, attending the festivals, and making the sacrifices, it’d be easier to swallow...
The Trouble with Jesus: hero vs antagonist. God’s Son battles his antithesis in a kind of hell.
By Constance Hastings February 19, 2026
All heroes have an antagonist, one who pushes hard against the best parts of who you are and what your purpose is. Fitting then, God’s beloved Son would meet the total antithesis of who he was before he even got out of that hot place, a kind of hell. Not surprisingly, the great tempter appears.
The Trouble with Jesus: Treasures most dear to God are the ashes  of our lives.
By Constance Hastings February 15, 2026
The Trouble with Jesus means our treasures are most dear to God when they are the ashes of our lives. Whatever upholds justice and love of neighbor is what God desires.
The Trouble with Jesus: He doesn’t give answers that satisfy; instead, he leads to new heights.
By Constance Hastings February 9, 2026
Any who have ever had a mountaintop experience will tell you, it’s nothing that can be planned, arranged, or scheduled. Spiritual encounters come out of the blue, filled with insights, revelations not previously perceived but somehow needed and relevant to a moment or period of life. And they never last. If anything, they serve as touchstones reminding of the source of that power, power greater than oneself in God who was, is and will always be.
The Trouble with Jesus: Sometimes he brought things together that might not  be a good idea.
By Constance Hastings February 2, 2026
Some things just won’t mix or at least shouldn’t: water and oil, light and dark, ammonia and bleach. One will rise above the other, cancel the other out, or react dangerously to anyone around. Throwing salt into a mix could either add flavor or kill off where it landed. Sometimes, Jesus brought things together that might not be a good idea.
The Trouble with Jesus: His words lead from the trouble in life.
By Constance Hastings January 26, 2026
Jesus, what really doesn’t make sense is how you say this on your first big stage. Here you are speaking from a first-century arena, on a mountain with your main guys in front and crowds filling in behind. Son of Man, people are seeing you and thinking this is like Moses bringing down the Big Ten from God’s mountain. They want to know again what God is going to do for them as a nation and in their own lives. And all you have are these platitudes?
The Trouble with Jesus: Don't ignore the context of his narrative.
By Constance Hastings January 19, 2026
There’s the narrative, and then there’s the context of that narrative. Should the writer have been more specific, this message may have been banned and burned before its distribution. Ruling powers control the narrative and won’t allow what makes them look less than the shine on their crowns. Sound familiar?
The Trouble with Jesus is aimed at a collective redirection of humankind.
By Constance Hastings January 12, 2026
Jesus, you dump on us that which doesn’t seem like anything until we get a peek at what’s underneath. That’s why we stand off on the side, find it hard to trust what you say, who you are, if you’re real. Yeah, make it easy on yourself, let us slide by this one with our eyes shut.
The Trouble with Jesus: Reversals are necessary. Position for change...
By Constance Hastings January 3, 2026
Here we are, the first full week of a new year, and do we ever need one. Sure, much has happened that we didn’t see coming, but we’re almost too familiar with that now. The thing is, are we willing to accept, buy into, focus on what that means? Will we have influence, impact, or at least be open to any newness of life in the coming months? Or again, will we passively accept what has been without resolution to change? Life must be positioned for change. Prepare to Pivot.
The Trouble with Jesus: His conversations sometimes take you deeper than you want to go
By Constance Hastings March 2, 2026
The Trouble with Jesus: His conversations don’t stay on the surface, sometimes pulling you deeper than you want to go. He drags you into the deep end before you even realize you’re swimming.
The Trouble with Jesus: He wouldn’t water his message into how people wanted to hear it.
By Constance Hastings February 23, 2026
Maybe it was just the way Jesus said it. Maybe if he had said that you gotta change your life and priorities without losing yourself, it’d make more sense. Maybe if he had said you find God by keeping the commandments, attending the festivals, and making the sacrifices, it’d be easier to swallow...
The Trouble with Jesus: hero vs antagonist. God’s Son battles his antithesis in a kind of hell.
By Constance Hastings February 19, 2026
All heroes have an antagonist, one who pushes hard against the best parts of who you are and what your purpose is. Fitting then, God’s beloved Son would meet the total antithesis of who he was before he even got out of that hot place, a kind of hell. Not surprisingly, the great tempter appears.
The Trouble with Jesus: Treasures most dear to God are the ashes  of our lives.
By Constance Hastings February 15, 2026
The Trouble with Jesus means our treasures are most dear to God when they are the ashes of our lives. Whatever upholds justice and love of neighbor is what God desires.
The Trouble with Jesus: He doesn’t give answers that satisfy; instead, he leads to new heights.
By Constance Hastings February 9, 2026
Any who have ever had a mountaintop experience will tell you, it’s nothing that can be planned, arranged, or scheduled. Spiritual encounters come out of the blue, filled with insights, revelations not previously perceived but somehow needed and relevant to a moment or period of life. And they never last. If anything, they serve as touchstones reminding of the source of that power, power greater than oneself in God who was, is and will always be.
The Trouble with Jesus: Sometimes he brought things together that might not  be a good idea.
By Constance Hastings February 2, 2026
Some things just won’t mix or at least shouldn’t: water and oil, light and dark, ammonia and bleach. One will rise above the other, cancel the other out, or react dangerously to anyone around. Throwing salt into a mix could either add flavor or kill off where it landed. Sometimes, Jesus brought things together that might not be a good idea.
The Trouble with Jesus: His words lead from the trouble in life.
By Constance Hastings January 26, 2026
Jesus, what really doesn’t make sense is how you say this on your first big stage. Here you are speaking from a first-century arena, on a mountain with your main guys in front and crowds filling in behind. Son of Man, people are seeing you and thinking this is like Moses bringing down the Big Ten from God’s mountain. They want to know again what God is going to do for them as a nation and in their own lives. And all you have are these platitudes?
The Trouble with Jesus: Don't ignore the context of his narrative.
By Constance Hastings January 19, 2026
There’s the narrative, and then there’s the context of that narrative. Should the writer have been more specific, this message may have been banned and burned before its distribution. Ruling powers control the narrative and won’t allow what makes them look less than the shine on their crowns. Sound familiar?
The Trouble with Jesus is aimed at a collective redirection of humankind.
By Constance Hastings January 12, 2026
Jesus, you dump on us that which doesn’t seem like anything until we get a peek at what’s underneath. That’s why we stand off on the side, find it hard to trust what you say, who you are, if you’re real. Yeah, make it easy on yourself, let us slide by this one with our eyes shut.
The Trouble with Jesus: Reversals are necessary. Position for change...
By Constance Hastings January 3, 2026
Here we are, the first full week of a new year, and do we ever need one. Sure, much has happened that we didn’t see coming, but we’re almost too familiar with that now. The thing is, are we willing to accept, buy into, focus on what that means? Will we have influence, impact, or at least be open to any newness of life in the coming months? Or again, will we passively accept what has been without resolution to change? Life must be positioned for change. Prepare to Pivot.