The Trouble with Jesus

by Constance Hastings

Cheap Charity/Second Sight
March 13, 2023

The Trouble with Jesus has to be read with a second sight, a reading beyond what you’ve seen before.

Right now, we all would like a big dose of cheap charity. Inflation, a bank failure, devastating storms every week, a war that won’t end, cancer affecting every family, ugly politics, God, make all this go away. Bless us with a life that is easy. Amen. Like the blind man, fix what I need. I want to not have to think about how people suffer, my people hurt, I hurt. Most of all, heal everybody that’s sick and make sure no one else gets it. Amen again. Oh yeah, especially don’t make us have to go through another economic recession or lose any money because of this. That cost is way too high. Amen and Amen.

 

Sorry, but for whatever reason God has, that’s not happening or happening like we want or as fast as we’d like. Deal with it. Take responsibility for what you can change, and support the people who have the means and power to make those changes. If it’s your passion, follow it. Be proactive in your own health. Remove your support for what is not healthy, what’s just downright wrong by making lifestyle changes. Adjust people.

 

Land of the Free

So what gives you the right to order people around, tell us how we’re supposed to live? You don’t live my life. You know, this is supposed to be the land of the free. I’m free to do what I want. Just stay out of it.

 

If only we all could look the other way, shrug our shoulders when people whine and complain something is wrong and blame everyone else, even God. Understand though, we’re not in this life alone. Think about a mobile where different figures are suspended but also connected to a central cord. If just one is moved, the whole thing shakes. Whatever we do affects others and eventually ripples out to the community, the world. Take another look and see how both the good and bad, the positive and negative all have impact beyond its start and ultimate source. From that, develop a second sight, perspectives which see with new eyes.

 

And while we’re on the subject, the Trouble with Jesus has to be read with a second sight, a reading beyond what you’ve seen before.

 

Like this story, one which had all the elements of the usual formula: someone needs healing, the disciples make a few inane comments, the Pharisees don’t like it (oops, it’s the Sabbath again), Jesus heals the person anyway, and one more person believes. You’d think there could be some kind of narrative twist along the Gospel way, but hey, it sells well. Just look at Hallmark movies or HGTV home makeovers. It’s the same plot every time. Why complicate the story line with anything more? Move to the next chapter. Start the story again.

 

No, go back. Take another look. Then read ahead and go back again.

 

It’s interesting often how the writers who tell Jesus’ story either seem to be talking about the next thing to happen or comment on the last event in a slightly different way. In the next chapter Jesus talks about sheep:  He said, “I am the good shepherd; I know my own sheep and they know me.” If so, what did Jesus know about this man who was healed, and what did he then know about Jesus?

 

Cheap Charity

As said before, it happened as it often did. Jesus’ disciples came upon a blind man. Sick people were around them all the time. They asked Jesus whose sin brought this disease on the poor guy. There’s the blame-game again. Jesus says no one sinned, but the man was born blind for God’s glory. (Thanks a lot for that one, God!) Then saying there’s not much time left in the day to work, Jesus says he is “the light of the world.”

 

With those thoughts spinning in everyone’s head, Jesus spits in the dirt, makes mud which he spreads on the guy’s eyes, and tells him to go wash in a nearby pool. The man comes back seeing. Praise God then! Story over, all should be well.

 

Blindsight

Not so. For the love of God, no one seems happy about this guy’s change of vision. First, some of his own neighbors don’t seem to recognize him now that he can see. Then, the Pharisees have their turn at him, interrogating him over what happened and getting all bent out of shape about it being the Sabbath. He’s  been blind ever since he was born, and the religious bureaucrats quibble among themselves if a healing (like that kind of thing happens everyday) is appropriate on a holy day. Then these Temple officials drag in his parents who do their best to stay out of the issue all but disowning their own son. When that doesn’t work, they call in the poor guy a second time.

 

Now maybe he can see, but he certainly didn’t see what was coming next. The legal mongers want the man to say Jesus is a sinner. He won’t bite but sticks to the facts. “But I know this: I was blind, and now I can see!” Refusing to give them what they want, he insists, “If this man were not born from God, he couldn’t do it.” Bam! He gets the boot and is thrown out of the synagogue. This glory ride for God is going nowhere good fast.

 

Second Sight

Jesus though knows his sheep. The good shepherd finds the man and starts a conversation. Interestingly, the man actually has never seen Jesus. He was healed of a lifetime of blindness, but Jesus wasn’t present when the man came back from the pool. Jesus talks with him now, but the man had no idea the one before him was his healer.

 

Jesus reveals himself as the Son of God. With that recognition, believing, now fully seeing, the man worships Jesus, his Shepherd and knows him for who he is. The one who brought the light of sight to him is the Light of the World.

 

I have come to give sight to the blind

 and to show those who think they see that they are blind.”


 

John 9:1-41


Subscribe to The Trouble with Jesus Blog Here.

 

The Trouble with Jesus: His stories make God look desperately unsatisfied, on the prowl for more.
By Constance Hastings September 8, 2025
The Trouble with Jesus: His stories make God look desperately unsatisfied, on the prowl for more, regardless of whether they’re lost or don’t know how lost they are.
The Trouble with Jesus: He made a life lesson on humility into a blessed honor.
By Constance Hastings August 31, 2025
Jesus, you are the perfect example of the observation, “When you are invited to a dinner, you are either a guest or you are part of a menu.” Everybody is always watching you, sizing you up, holding their breath to see what you might do next. You look like you’re there to eat as much as you’re there to preach.
The Trouble with Jesus: His rhetoric doesn’t permit a domestication of lifestyle covered by religion
By Constance Hastings August 25, 2025
The Trouble with Jesus: His scandalous rhetoric doesn’t permit domestication of lifestyle covered with a veneer of religion.
The Trouble with Jesus: ihe brings upheaval into how the world works, even when it hurts his cause
By Constance Hastings August 18, 2025
This reads like Jesus is being attacked for healing on the Sabbath. It's more than that which brings big trouble. Jesus was breaking Sabbath by breaking perceptions of what the social and religious structure of the world should be, wreaking and crumbling the caste system of the entire religious culture.
Truth Burns: The Trouble with Jesus is he makes political divisions look tame.
By Constance Hastings August 11, 2025
You know what, Jesus? This makes you certified dangerous. So you’re going to bring fire, division and family dysfunction? Like we need your divine help on this one. Incendiary talk won’t get you votes on making our world better. More like, arrested and put away for good. Yeah, you ask for it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he both brings and requires reversals.
By Constance Hastings August 4, 2025
Jesus. We need help. No, make that, you need help. Whatever. You spin this talk about treasure in heaven and then getting robbed. About being the revered master and then acting like you’re the slave. Come on here. Say what you mean and quit making it so hard for us to get it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he talks too much about your money.
By Constance Hastings July 28, 2025
It’s not the accumulation of wealth that’s the problem. You’re right though, Jesus had a lot to say about money. In some places he talks about it more than prayer. In the end, that being this blog and your life, it would pay for you to listen up to this story of The Rich Fool.
The Trouble with Jesus is he teaches God answers prayers by not always giving us what we ask.
By Constance Hastings July 21, 2025
Relationship is what God wants out of prayers and this is how God wants it understood. God and you have this thing going. You two need to talk. What follows is a structure to this particular prayer, the Lord's Prayer, but each part is a prayer unto itself. Talk it over with God where you are in it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he doesn’t take just one side.
By Constance Hastings July 14, 2025
Jesus, on this one we have to give it to you. You didn’t send Mary back to the kitchen just because she was a woman....Well, thanks, but not so fast. If you are assuming this is some kind of feminist liberation call, you’re two steps behind and five miles ahead. Jesus didn’t go around saying that kind of thing...
The Trouble with Jesus: He consistently pushes up against the expected parameters of love.
By Constance Hastings July 6, 2025
Jesus’ stories knock around in the soul with his aim of reversing, redirecting, twisting what one has been taught to believe.